Eye Makeup
Product Comparisons
Eye cosmetics can be extremely irritating, especially if you wear contact lenses. The products below contain ingredients less likely to aggravate sensitive eyes, and they don't contain brain-damaging mercury, found in some eye cosmetics as a preservative. For more information on the ugly side of the beauty industry, see The Backstory.
Wondering what these table headings mean? They're the criteria we used to choose and evaluate the products in the chart below. Learn more about their importance in What To Look For.
| Name | Dirty-Dozen Free | Third Party Certification | Compact for Safe Cosmetics | Vegan? | Ingredients Available Online | Packaging | MSRP | Purchasing Information | Reader Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Hauschka Eyeliner | X | BDIH | X | $16.95 | www.drhauschka.com, 800-247-9907 |
Avg. Rating 
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Dr. Hauschka Eyeshadow Solo | X | BDIH | X | $17.95 | www.drhauschka.com, 800-247-9907 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Dr. Hauschka Liquid Eyeliner | X | BDIH | X | $16.95 | www.drhauschka.com, 800-247-9907 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Dr. Hauschka Mascara Intermezzo | X | BDIH | X | $23.50 | www.drhauschka.com, 800-247-9907 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Dr. Hauschka Volume Mascara | X | BDIH | X | $23.50 | www.drhauschka.com, 800-247-9907 |
Avg. Rating 
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Earth's Beauty Soft Black Mascara | X | Leaping Bunny | X | X | $7.95 | www.allnaturalbeauty.com, 888-586-9719 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Ecco Bella FlowerColor Eyeshadow | X | X | X | X | aluminum | $9.95 | www.eccobella.com, 877-696-2220 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Ecco Bella FlowerColor Powder Eyeliner | X | X | X | X | aluminum | $9.95 | www.eccobella.com, 877-696-2220 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Ecco Bella Shimmer Dust (eyeshadow/face powder) | X | X | X | X | aluminum | $9.95 | www.eccobella.com, 877-696-2220 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Ecco Bella Soft Eyeliner Pencils | X | X | X | X | wood | $14.95 | www.eccobella.com, 877-696-2220 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Gabriel Cosmetics Color Eyeshadow | X | Leaping Bunny | X | X | $10.30 | www.gabrielcosmeticsinc.com, 800-497-6419 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Honeybee Gardens JobaColors Eye Liner | X | X | X | $6.99 | www.honeybeegardens.com, 610-396-9225 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara | X | X | X | #2 HDPE | $9.99 | www.honeybeegardens.com, 610-396-9225 |
Avg. Rating
1 Reader Comment Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Lavera Eyeliner | X | BDIH | X | X* | #1 PET | $15.00 | www.lavera.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Lavera Eyeshadow Duo | X | BDIH | X | X | X* | #1 PET | $24.00 | www.lavera.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
| Lavera Volume Mascara | X | BDIH | X | X | X* | #1 PET | $22.00 | www.lavera.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
| Logona Eyebrow Pencil | X | BDIH | X | X | $9.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Logona Eyeshadow Pencils | X | BDIH | X | X | $9.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Logona Eyeshadow Powder Duo | X | BDIH | X | X | $13.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Logona Liquid Eyeliner | X | BDIH | X | X | $13.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Logona Mascaras | X | BDIH | X | X | $13.99 | www.1stenvirosafetyinc.com, 888-578-9600 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Miessence Pure Black Mascara | X | Australian Certified Organic | X | X | $24.50 | www.mionegroup.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Nvey Eco Organic Cake Eyeliner | X | Organic Food Chain | X | X | $24.00 | www.econveybeauty.com, 859-261-7895 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Nvey Eco Organic Eye Shadow | X | Organic Food Chain | X | X | $24.00 | www.econveybeauty.com, 859-261-7895 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Paul Penders Nutritious Color Eye Pencils | X | X | X | $7.00 | www.paulpenders.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Real Purity Mascara | X | X | X | $23.99 | www.realpurity.com, 800-253-1694 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Sante Kosmetics Eyeliner Pencil | X | BDIH | X | $6.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Sante Kosmetics Eyeshadow Pencils | X | BDIH | X | $9.50 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Sante Kosmetics Eyeshadow Powders | X | BDIH | X | $10.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|||
| Sante Kosmetics Mascara | X | BDIH | X | X | $11.99 | www.naturaleurope.com |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Suki Color Rich Pigment Mascara | X | Leaping Bunny | X | X | aluminum | $31.50 | www.sukicolor.com, 888-858-7854 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Suki Color Triple Cream Eye Definer | X | Leaping Bunny | X | X | glass | $38.50 | www.sukicolor.com, 888-858-7854 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
|
| Suncoat Cosmetics Loose Powder Eye Shadow | X | X | X (except purple) | X | $8.99 | www.suncoatproducts.com, 519-820-5468 |
Avg. Rating
1 Reader Comment Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Suncoat Cosmetics Natural Mascara | X | X | X | X | $14.99 | www.suncoatproducts.com, 519-820-5468 |
Avg. Rating
2 Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Suncoat Cosmetics Roll-On Organic Eyeshadow | X | X | X (except purple) | X | $14.99 | www.suncoatproducts.com, 519-820-5468 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| Suncoat Cosmetics Sugar Based Liquid Eyeliner | X | X | X | X | $16.99 | www.suncoatproducts.com, 519-820-5468 |
Avg. Rating
Reader Comments Rate/Review This Product |
||
| *Product ingredients available at www.cosmeticsdatabase.com | |||||||||